It
wasn’t until I started reading Ghost World that I became interested in graphic
novels. I even started looking for more exemplars of graphic novels and I
realized their potential to be used as a student-friendly material that can
eventually increase motivation in students when it comes to reading and, in
turn, hopefully enhance reading and writing abilities.
You may start reading graphic novels as an
assignment and end up reading them for pleasure because there is something
appealing about its format; the images that can stand on its own and can still
mean 1000 word, the mixture of text and images, the black & white or coloured
panels that engages and makes it really
easy to read.
However, here I would
like to digress a bit from the main point I’m trying to put forward, to assert
that images in graphic novels must not be thought as just visual representation
to support what is being written, but images also represent concepts that we
immediately recognize because we have “unintendedly” conventionally agreed on
its meaning as a way to understand reality.
Bringing this point to Daniel Clowes’s Ghost World, there is a part in which Enid enters a sex shop and instead of purchasing any object related to sex she
just gets a “mask” of Catwoman. This is key to understand the character and in
part the plot of this graphic novel; the Catwoman mask is a sex symbol since,
culturally, we know that people get this “customs” for sexual purposes;
however, Enid wears this mask in everyday life and breaks with the conception
of this mask as a sexual icon. This clearly reflects the character’s attempt to
go against the “culturally established”, not caring about what people think.
In the case of Art Spiegelman’s Maus, something similar happens. To help the reader understand what
occurred in the Holocaust and to imagine the relationship between Nazis and
Jews, the author employs the images of cats and mice as a metaphor. Since we
conventionally know that cats are the natural predators of mice (even though I’ve
never seen a cat hunting a mouse) we can assert that the cats represent the
Nazis chasing and capturing mice, the Jews.
Coming back to graphic novels and its application in classrooms, I’ve discovered that many topics have been covered in graphic novels and would be a great idea to introduce certain contents in the classroom by using graphic novels. Whether it is a serious matter like the Holocaust, one of the most horrible events in history or whether it is a teenage story like the one presented in Ghost World, graphic novels can be a very useful tool to engage students in reading because of both content and format.
Finally here’s the
link with the 50 best graphic novels (Ghost World in number 17 and Maus in
number 5) in case you are looking for more graphic novels to read, there is a
brief summary of each one of them.
I have to admit that I never thought about graphic novels as a material for teaching. But now that you have made your point, I totally agree with you. There are some (too many) students who don't like to read and even though reading a book may be an asignment, they simply don't read just because they don't want to. In those cases reading a graphic novel can be a really good idea. Since graphic novels are based on pictures, it would be engaging for learners, it also could promote their creativity.
ResponderEliminarOn the other hand, we have those contents that are so relevant for the students' education, for example, the Nazi Regime. And as you said, those kinds of topic can be introduced by a graphic novel like Maus, where such a horrible matter was presented in a 'delicate' way.
Paulina, I totally agree with you because I am a clear example of that motivation produced by the images, and actually I talked about that in post, based on how this concept of graphic novel engaged me. I love reading for pleasure, but when it is about compulsory reading for University for example, I tend to get exhausted, and that was my predisposition before reading Maus.
ResponderEliminarIn my opinion this is a tool that should be used more in schools, since teachers are supposed to cover all the multiple intelligences this would be a perfect idea to help children with visual and reading and writing preferences. As you said before images can replace lots of words and a simple gesture in some character’s face makes you think about what is going on, and that helps students to develop their ability to analyze, which helps to understand better the context of the novel and what the author is trying to express.