domingo, 22 de junio de 2014

Our Ghost world


I was not really into graphic novels nor comics until I read Maus and Ghost world, I found it a very special genre in literature, because with a short dialogue and just one image the author is capable of creating a whole story in our minds. It is also remarkable the fact that graphic novelists have a great talent when writing and drawing.


Ghost world is a clear refection of life, and of how we see each other, and as Raúl explained very well on his post, how we believe we see each other.

The characrter of Enid is quite special and reflects a lot of what postmodernism is, to criticize and to care only about yourself.That is shown in many aspects of the novel, for instance, when she and rebecca call a man  pretending to be "the redhead" with the only purpose of laugh at him. They are always criticizing people around them, even their friends, at the end of the novel, they are individualistic even with temselves, they are not the "team" anymore, and enid leave the town without her friend.


As I see it, we all are like them, we criticize everyone, their looks, their outfits, their behaviour, their likes, etc. And I do not think it is wrong at all, I mean it is part of our society, of the time in history that we are living in,just like Hemingway's characters in The sun also rises, and their lives after both World Wars, as the modernist poets, criticizing and questioning this new era, as Vladek Spiegelman acts after the horrors that he had to suffer, and so on.

All things considered, now that we are in a port-modernist context (or post-postmodernism) we cannot fall on deaf ears and pretend that we all care about each other and do not feel bother because of their likes or behaviours. In addition to that, we cannot left beheind the fact that the context influences literature, and how we interpret it.

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns

During the post Modern graphic novel period there many titles that got the audience attention, such as Art Spiegelman’s Maus, Alan Moore’s V for Vendetta, Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons’ Watchmen and Frank Miller’s Batman: The Dark Knight Returns. However, what make Batman stand up from other graphic novels of that time is that Batman was the first of the superhero comics to reinvent itself and target a new, more mature, audience.   
Batman was first published in 1940 and like most of the comic superheroes of that time was targeted to a more young audience, therefore the topics of the comic were mostly innocent and did not relate to the reality of the times. There were always a bad and a good character and no room for any kind of ambiguity.


But all change after the end of the cold war. The audience no longer wanted comics that did not reflect the reality of the world and the sells of comics dropped significantly. That is when Batman: The Dark Knight Returns makes it appearance in 1896 by the hand of Frank Miller but instead of a comic was more like a graphic novel. Under frank’s style, Batman became more darker and mysterious than before with more adult and complex themes.

As a comic lover, I have always had a special place in my heart for Batman. In contrast with other superheroes like Superman, Batman was more fierce and sarcastic and were times in which i was not so sure if Batman was one of the good boys or one of the bad boys. Also, Batman was a regular person (if you consider a billionaire, fitness fit person normal). He did not have any super power besides his own intelligence and human gadgets.


I know a lot of people do not like superhero comics, because of this clean, nationalized (American) appearance they portrait. But if you ask me, i would advise you to give Batman a try because I do not think you would regret it.

HATERS GONNA HATE


   It seems that lot of people are quite fond into criticizing and looking contemptuously over someone’s ways of dressing up, taste of music, etc.
The truth is that all these people that go around criticizing have a social resentment caused by their feeling of not belonging or not having being able to fit in a world in which only certain people are considered beautiful and successful.
I personally believe that those who criticize the most are the one that would love to be part of that trivial trend if the opportunity ever arises. On the other side those who really dislike something, would try to avoid talking about it and it would become something invisible and worthless.

Nevertheless, it is been said that trends are fleeting, therefore only real beauty will prevalence. So I do not see the point in trying to making others feel bad for what they like or believe. 



Postmodernist elements in Neon Genesis Evangelion

In class we saw an overview of postmodernism and some of its characteristics, evidenced in the two graphic novels we were required to read. So as not to repeat the same information from other posts, I thought it would be interesting to take the elements usually associated with postmodernism and use them to analyze a very popular anime/manga, Neon Genesis Evangelion.
Neon Genesis Evangelion Logo

As seen in class, postmodernism is very skeptical of models, categories, and any claim valid for a group instead of each person’s relative truth.  Reality is questioned, reality is nothing.  The reality we know is only our own interpretation of the world. In modernity there is a search for meaning even where there is none. There is a search for truth. However, in postmodernism there seems to be a lack of optimism of there being a truth that answers all questions. This was brought on by the devastation of two world wars. Post modernity is full of questions, which is why postmodern works tend not to conclude with a neatly tied-up ending.

Postmodern elements can be found in Neon Genesis Evangelion.  According to Anno Hideki, the creator, evangelion takes place along the following schemata:

The year: 2015
A world where, fifteen years before, over half the human population perished.
A world that has been miraculously revived: its economy, the production, circulation, consumption of material goods, so that even the shelves of convenience stores are filled.
A world where the people have gotten [sic] used to the resurrection - yet still feel the end of the world is destined to come.
A world where the number of children, the future leaders of the world, is few.
A world where Japan saw the original Tokyo destroyed, discarded and forgotten, and built a new capital in Nagano Prefecture. They constructed a new capital, Tokyo-2, then left it to be a decoy - then constructed another new capital, Tokyo-3, and tried to make it safe from attack.
A world where some completely unknown enemy called the 'Angels' comes to ravage the cities.
This is roughly the worldview for Neon Genesis Evangelion.
This is a worldview drenched in a vision of pessimism.
A worldview where the story starts only after any traces of optimism have been removed.
And in that world, a 14-year-old boy shrinks from human contact.
And he tries to live in a closed world where his behavior dooms him, and he has abandoned the attempt to understand himself.
A cowardly young man who feels that his father has abandoned him, and so he has convinced himself that he is a completely unnecessary person, so much so that he cannot even commit suicide. (Anno Hideaki, reprinted in Evangelion Manga accessed 27 January, 2002, originally from (July 17 1995) Viz Comics.)

The series itself is an example of pastiche since it combines multiple genres. Ask anyone who has watched the show and they would say that it is not just your run of the mill mecha (robot) type show. Although the anime starts out with futurist fantasy and mecha elements, the central narrative and characters are later devolved and deconstructed.  There are a number of allusions to biological , military, religious, and psychological concepts. There are also references to older anime series. Intertextuality can also be highly evidenced in this series. However, I will not delve into the topic as it would take up too much space. 

More than the battle with the angels, Neon Genesis Evangelion is about the battle in ones own thoughts. In the last episodes of Evangelion reality and individuality are questioned.  For example:

“Is this the world where everything is set?” Shinji (main character)  asks his projection of Misato (another character).

“No,” she replies, “This is the world where you are the setting.”

Image

Another example is the following conversation that the main character has with himself:

"Where am I?
What the hell am I?
[speaking to himself] So, you need the barrier of the mind.
What? It's me. The shape that I show to others. The symbol representing me. This, and this, and this, all these are representations of me. Nothing but the things that make others recognise me.
What am I? Is this me? The true me? The false me?"


Finally, Neon Genesis Evangelion ended without answering all the questions that had surfaced throughout the series. There is no neatly tied up ending. Many who viewed the series even reacted negatively towards the ending as it was too confusing and resolved nothing. We are too used to having everything answered for us. If watched carefully, the series actually did have some answers for us, but not the answers of the entire story as a whole. As stated above, there are a number of elements that can be analyzed from Evangelion. This was just a brief overview. I highly recommend watching the series and gathering your own interpretation of the story and how postmodern elements are interwoven into the anime.

A father-son relationship in Maus

When I started reading this book, I realized there was a strong theme in which Vladek and Art were immersed, the relationship between both of them. I am sure that Vladek and Art loved each other, but there was a sense of hatred at the same time from son to father, because all the privacy events that Vladek passed through during the Holocaust, and also because Art’s father did not share anything with his son until he asked him this story in order to write this book.

There are two good examples in which I want to focus my attention; the first one is when Art asked his father about his mother’s diaries, he cannot forgive that he burnt them all, consequently Art called his father a murderer, because he thought he killed his mother for a second time, he wanted this diaries while he was depressed because all the pain he suffered from the past, from the holocaust, from his lost.

The other example that I want to highlight is when Vladek wakes his son very early in the morning because he wanted him to help fixing gutter on the roof, but for the reason that of the relationship between them all, he refuses to help his father and wants to feel guilty about it. Time after that, when he grew up, he decided to go to his father’s house in order to remedy the past event, he asked his father for any help, because he felt that the guilty had grown. Till now, Art thinks that he could never forget this sense of pain, despite the fact that his father is dead, he regrets about it.

All things considered, I found blissfully interesting, the fact that Art goes to his father, and asks him about his stories, his experiences in order to create this autobiographical book, Maus. The way Spielgeman adds such a lot of elements, for instance the Holocaust, suicide, anger let me think how great his work is, and in addition to that how he through commix, developed this book, let us know about his father’s experiences being a survivor of the Holocaust, and about his own life.   

What if Vladek had not burnt his wife's diaries? Do you believe that their relationship would have been the same?



Images and the Graphic Novels: Their potential for teaching

 It wasn’t until I started reading Ghost World that I became interested in graphic novels. I even started looking for more exemplars of graphic novels and I realized their potential to be used as a student-friendly material that can eventually increase motivation in students when it comes to reading and, in turn, hopefully enhance reading and writing abilities.

 You may start reading graphic novels as an assignment and end up reading them for pleasure because there is something appealing about its format; the images that can stand on its own and can still mean 1000 word, the mixture of text and images, the black & white or coloured panels  that engages and makes it really easy to read.

However, here I would like to digress a bit from the main point I’m trying to put forward, to assert that images in graphic novels must not be thought as just visual representation to support what is being written, but images also represent concepts that we immediately recognize because we have “unintendedly” conventionally agreed on its meaning as a way to understand reality.

Bringing this point to Daniel Clowes’s Ghost World, there is a part in which Enid enters a sex shop and instead of purchasing any object related to sex she just gets a “mask” of Catwoman. This is key to understand the character and in part the plot of this graphic novel; the Catwoman mask is a sex symbol since, culturally, we know that people get this “customs” for sexual purposes; however, Enid wears this mask in everyday life and breaks with the conception of this mask as a sexual icon. This clearly reflects the character’s attempt to go against the “culturally established”, not caring about what people think.


In the case of Art Spiegelman’s Maus, something similar happens. To help the reader understand what occurred in the Holocaust and to imagine the relationship between Nazis and Jews, the author employs the images of cats and mice as a metaphor. Since we conventionally know that cats are the natural predators of mice (even though I’ve never seen a cat hunting a mouse) we can assert that the cats represent the Nazis chasing and capturing mice, the Jews.




Coming back to graphic novels and its application in classrooms, I’ve discovered that many topics have been covered in graphic novels and would be a great idea to introduce certain contents in the classroom by using graphic novels. Whether it is a serious matter like the Holocaust, one of the most horrible events in history or whether it is a teenage story like the one presented in Ghost World, graphic novels can be a very useful tool to engage students in reading because of both content and format.

Finally here’s the link with the 50 best graphic novels (Ghost World in number 17 and Maus in number 5) in case you are looking for more graphic novels to read, there is a brief summary of each one of them.


[Volume 1: Scott Pilgrim's Precious Little Life][Watchmen (Titan Edition)][Alice In Sunderland (Hardcover)][Volume 1: Preludes And Nocturnes]